Inventur & Warenwirtschaft

Supplier evaluation in hospitality: criteria, scoring system and example

Supplier evaluation in hospitality: criteria, a weighted scoring system and a worked example – plus where to get price and delivery data.

Lukas Graf

Lukas Graf

Managing Director

9 min

Reading time

Supplier evaluation in hospitality: criteria, scoring system and example

The delivery arrives an hour late, two cases of tonic are missing, and on the next invoice the gin has gone up again. Each incident on its own seems minor. Together, though, they decide whether your cost of goods is right and whether everything is in stock on Friday night. Supplier evaluation turns these individual incidents into a clear number: you see in black and white which supplier is reliable, who is quietly getting more expensive and who you should talk to.

In this guide you will learn which criteria matter for bars, restaurants and hotels, how to build a simple weighted scoring system and how to compare two suppliers in a fully worked example. We also show you where to get the data without spending hours on paper documents.

1. What is supplier evaluation?

Supplier evaluation is the systematic assessment of your suppliers' performance against criteria defined in advance. The Wikipedia definition (in German) compares it to a rating: the aim is transparency about supplier performance, a well-founded selection and better collaboration. It lists, among others, price, lead time, adherence to delivery dates and quantities, and quality, plus softer factors such as cooperation and communication.

In industry, supplier evaluation is a fixed part of purchasing and quality management. In hospitality, it often happens only in people's heads: you have a feeling for who delivers well. That is enough as long as everything runs smoothly. As soon as prices rise, staff change or you open a second site, you need traceable figures.

2. Why supplier evaluation matters in hospitality

Your suppliers determine three things that directly affect your results:

  • Cost of goods: every price increase you miss goes straight into your cost of goods. Our guide on calculating cost of goods shows how to determine it correctly.
  • Availability: if an item is missing, you buy expensively elsewhere or take a drink off the menu. Both cost revenue or margin.
  • Quality and food safety: wrong temperatures, short shelf life or damaged goods lead to spoilage and complaints.

There is also a legal side: as a food business operator you must be able to identify who supplied your food under Article 18 of Regulation (EC) No 178/2002. The regulation applies directly in Germany and Austria. In Switzerland, Art. 83 of the Food and Utility Articles Ordinance (LGV) requires you to be able to tell the authorities who you obtained products from. These rules do not prescribe a points-based evaluation. But if you already document your suppliers properly, you have the basis for an evaluation at hand.

3. The most important criteria for your supplier evaluation

Five criteria have proven themselves for hospitality businesses. What matters is that you make each criterion measurable, otherwise the evaluation stays at gut-feeling level.

  • Price and price stability: compare a fixed reference basket of your most important items, for example gin, tonic, draught beer, limes and beef rump. That shows you who is cheaper overall and who raises prices how often.
  • On-time delivery: share of deliveries that arrive within the agreed time window. Formula: on-time deliveries ÷ all deliveries × 100.
  • Order accuracy: share of ordered lines delivered completely and correctly. Formula: completely delivered lines ÷ ordered lines × 100.
  • Quality: number of complaints, for example due to wrong temperature, damaged containers or too short a best-before date. What to check on arrival is explained in our article on goods receipt inspection.
  • Service: delivery days, minimum order value, availability when problems arise, goodwill with complaints. This criterion is more subjective, so it is best scored by the team that receives the goods.

Depending on your venue, further criteria may be added, such as regional sourcing, organic share, taking back empties or correct documents. Wrong quantities or prices on delivery notes and invoices cost you time during invoice checking. Still, keep the list short: five to seven criteria are manageable, twenty are not.

4. Supplier evaluation with a scoring system: step by step

A proven method is weighted scoring, also known as a utility analysis. The Haufe explanation of the supplier selection method (in German) shows the principle: each criterion gets a score, which is multiplied by its importance (a ranking in Haufe's example), and the sum gives the overall rating per supplier. Here is how to proceed:

1
Define criteria
What matters for your venue?
2
Weight them
All weights add up to 100%
3
Collect data
Delivery notes, invoices, complaints
4
Score & act
Talk, backup supplier, switch

Step 1: Define criteria. Choose the criteria from section 3 that really matter for your venue. A cocktail bar with 500 items sets different priorities than a canteen with lots of fresh produce.

Step 2: Weight them. Distribute 100 percent across your criteria. An example for a beverage supplier: price 30%, on-time delivery 25%, order accuracy 20%, quality 15%, service 10%. For a fresh produce supplier you would weight quality higher.

Step 3: Collect data and award points. Set a scale of 1 to 5 points for each criterion, clearly defined in advance. For on-time delivery and order accuracy, this works well: 98% or more = 5 points, 95 to under 98% = 4, 90 to under 95% = 3, 85 to under 90% = 2, below that = 1. For price, the cheapest supplier gets 5 points, and each full 2% premium costs one point. For quality, count the complaints in the period: none = 5, one = 4, two = 3, three = 2, more = 1.

Step 4: Score and act. Multiply the points by the weighting and add everything up. Then group your suppliers, similar to the ‘preferred supplier’ and ‘supplier to be developed’ categories mentioned in the Wikipedia definition, for example 4.0 points or more as preferred supplier, 3.0 to under 4.0 as supplier with development needs, below 3.0 build up backup suppliers or consider switching. The last part is key: an evaluation only pays off if you use the results in conversations with the supplier.

5. Worked example: two beverage suppliers compared

A bar buys spirits and soft drinks from two suppliers. Last quarter, each made 25 deliveries with a total of 200 ordered lines. The raw data:

  • Supplier A: 23 of 25 deliveries on time (92%), 198 of 200 lines complete (99%), reference basket 1,035 €, one complaint, service rated 3 points by the team.
  • Supplier B: 22 of 25 deliveries on time (88%), 188 of 200 lines complete (94%), reference basket 1,000 €, one complaint, service rated 4 points.

Supplier A's basket is 3.5% more expensive than B's. The example scores only the basket price; you can add price stability from section 6 as a separate criterion. Using the scale from step 3, the points and weighted values are:

  • Price (30%): A 4 points = 1.20; B 5 points = 1.50
  • On-time delivery (25%): A 3 points = 0.75; B 2 points = 0.50
  • Order accuracy (20%): A 5 points = 1.00; B 3 points = 0.60
  • Quality (15%): A 4 points = 0.60; B 4 points = 0.60
  • Service (10%): A 3 points = 0.30; B 4 points = 0.40

Overall rating: supplier A 3.85 points, supplier B 3.60 points. Although B is cheaper, A comes out ahead because at B 6% of the ordered lines are not delivered completely and 12% of the deliveries arrive late. You have to source missing goods elsewhere at short notice, usually on worse terms. Both suppliers fall into the ‘needs development’ band. With A, a conversation about punctuality is worthwhile; with B, one about complete deliveries.

6. Keeping an eye on price trends

For the price criterion, a one-off comparison is not enough. Many price increases come in small steps that hardly stand out on a single invoice. Do the maths: with 4,000 € of monthly purchasing net, a 3% price increase is 120 € per month and therefore 1,440 € per year. If you do not raise your selling prices, your cost of goods rises by exactly this amount.

That is why ongoing price monitoring is part of supplier evaluation: record the purchase price per delivery for your most important items and compare it with the previous quarter. A supplier who raises prices often gets fewer points for price stability, even if the basket is still cheap. How purchase prices and order quantities interact is shown in our guide on the optimal order quantity.

88%
Example: on-time delivery rate of supplier B, 22 of 25 deliveries on time
94%
Example: order accuracy of supplier B, 188 of 200 lines complete
1,440 €
Example: extra cost per year from a 3% price increase on 4,000 € monthly purchasing
Example values: 25 deliveries with 200 ordered lines per quarter; monthly purchasing 4,000 € net, 3% price increase = 120 € per month.

The tiles summarise the example values: supplier B reaches 88% on-time delivery (22 of 25 deliveries on time) and 94% order accuracy (188 of 200 lines complete). The third tile shows what a 3% price increase on 4,000 € of monthly purchasing adds up to over a year.

7. Where does the data for the evaluation come from?

You already have most of the figures; they are just spread across different documents:

  • Delivery notes: delivered items and quantities plus the delivery date. What a delivery note should contain and how long to keep it is covered in our article on delivery notes in hospitality.
  • Invoices: purchase prices per item and thus the basis for price comparison and price trends.
  • Orders: what you ordered, as a reference for order accuracy.
  • Receiving log and complaints: delivery time, temperature, defects and how they were resolved.

The problem is the effort. If you copy delivery notes and invoices into spreadsheets by hand, you rarely do it consistently. Price changes then only show up in the monthly review, and incomplete deliveries are ticked off on paper and forgotten. That is why many supplier evaluations fail not because of the method but because of data capture.

8. Capturing data for supplier evaluation with BarBrain

With BarBrain's AI delivery note and invoice scanner you photograph delivery notes and invoices in the app or upload them on the web. The AI detects items, quantities, pack sizes and purchase prices and matches differing supplier descriptions to your items. If a supplier delivers a substitute item, the app asks whether it is the same item.

AI delivery note scannerSnap a photo, check, book with one click
Delivery note
Detected items
London Dry Gin 0.7 l12 btl.
Tonic Water 0.2 l48 btl.
Limes5 kg
Goods receiptBooked ✓
Example illustration: items are detected from the photo, checked and booked as a goods receipt with one click.

As the illustration shows, you check the detected items, for example 12 bottles of gin, 48 bottles of tonic and 5 kg of limes, and book the goods receipt with one click into the right area, such as the main bar. Your stock is then up to date. While checking, you see all delivered items with quantities at a glance and can compare them with your order. That is the basis for your order accuracy.

For the price criterion, one more point is decisive: changed purchase prices are shown during the scan. If gin goes up by 2.7% from 18.00 € to 18.49 € per 0.7-litre bottle, you see it immediately. The new prices flow into your items and into recipe management. In this example, the cost of goods for 4 cl of gin rises from 1.03 € to 1.06 €, and you decide on a current basis whether to adjust the drink price or negotiate with the supplier.

The table summarises the difference:

Task
Without BarBrain
With BarBrain
Capture delivery notes
Typing into spreadsheets
Photo, AI detects the items
Spot price changes
Only in the monthly review
Shown during the scan
Check the delivery
Ticking off a paper list
Check items, then book with one click
Cost of goods per drink
Based on old purchase prices
New prices flow into recipe costing

Without digital capture, you type delivery notes into spreadsheets, only notice price changes in the monthly review, tick off deliveries on paper and cost drinks with old purchase prices. With BarBrain, the AI does the capturing, price changes appear during the scan, you book with one click after checking, and recipe costing works with the new prices. If you run several outlets, each outlet has its own account with its own areas, and the admin overview keeps all accounts in view. You can find out more on the page for groups and hotels.

Want to see how this would look in your venue? Book a demo

9. Frequently asked questions

What is supplier evaluation?
Supplier evaluation is the systematic assessment of your suppliers against criteria defined in advance, such as price, on-time delivery, order accuracy, quality and service. Each criterion gets a weight and a score, which add up to an overall rating per supplier. That lets you compare suppliers in a traceable way instead of by gut feeling.
Which criteria matter most in hospitality?
For most venues, price and price stability, on-time delivery, complete delivery and product quality carry the most weight. For fresh produce, quality usually counts for more; for beverages, price and order accuracy. Set the weighting to suit your venue and keep it stable across several evaluation rounds.
How often should I evaluate my suppliers?
A quarterly rhythm is a good starting point for most venues, because by then there are enough deliveries for reliable figures. You can also keep an eye on your most important suppliers, for beverages or meat for example, every month. What matters is that you always use the same criteria and scales so the results stay comparable.
Is supplier evaluation mandatory in hospitality?
Food law mainly requires you to be able to identify who supplied your food: in the EU under Article 18 of Regulation (EC) No 178/2002, in Switzerland under Art. 83 of the Food and Utility Articles Ordinance (LGV). These rules do not prescribe a formal points-based evaluation. It is, however, an effective tool for steering purchasing costs and delivery quality.
How does BarBrain support supplier evaluation?
With the AI delivery note and invoice scanner you capture every delivery by photo or upload, and the AI detects items, quantities, pack sizes and purchase prices. Changed purchase prices are shown during the scan and flow into your recipe costing. The data on purchase prices and delivered quantities is created along the way, instead of you digging it out of paper documents.
Lukas Graf

About the author

Lukas Graf

Managing Director

Keep reading

All articles →

Free demo

Your next stocktake in half the time.

Book a free demo – 30 minutes, no obligation. We'll show you BarBrain using your own product range.

1,000+
Venues
80,000+
Stocktakes
up to70%
Time saved
✓ Stocktake complete
€9,672.55
Stock value · Main bar
Variance detected
−0.56 l gin
≙ 14 gin & tonics · ≈ €133 revenue
Delivery note
6× gin · cost price +2.7%